Poverty and its ramifications have become so critical to Nigerians that the issue has taken centre stage in national political discourse as the 2027 general elections draw nearer.
As part of the series in this column examining the needs of Nigerians as we prepare to elect new political leaders on January 16 for the President and National Assembly, and February 6 for governors and state legislators, I have been examining the issues at the top of Nigerians’ pressing concerns. How to overcome the current economic hardship being endured by a critical mass of Nigerians, as well as how to stem the ugly tide of insecurity and ensure the safety of lives and property, feature prominently as the top two concerns.
Before proceeding further, it is appropriate that we put things in perspective.
And I would like to do so by craving the indulgence of readers to permit me to reproduce as a preamble a summary of my article published in this column last week, titled “The Great Depression Lesson: Hoover versus Roosevelt, and Nigeria’s Choice,” which appeared on Tuesday, November 10.
We can commence by putting things in context by restating the fact that since May 29, 2023, when he assumed the mantle of leadership of Nigeria, President Tinubu’s reforms, particularly the removal of petrol subsidies and the unification of exchange rates, have triggered severe cost-of-living hardship. The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) estimates that these developments have plunged about 133 million Nigerians into heightened economic hardship.
Interestingly, both the ruling party and opposition leaders agree that Nigeria was on the verge of collapse and that reforms were necessary. However, a disagreement has emerged over how the removal of petrol subsidies should have been implemented. The point of divergence is between the shock-therapy approach of abruptly ending the subsidy regime, adopted by the ruling party, and the gradual approach preferred by most opposition parties.
Indeed, one opposition candidate has now promised to restore the subsidy, which is a major contributor to the current price distortions, if elected in 2027.
His message appears to be resonating with the masses, for better or worse, as he doubled down on the promise during his campaign tour of the North last week. But Tinubu has assured Nigerians that there is no going back to Egypt.
Who would voters on January 16 and February 6 , 2027 cast their vote for?
The question arises from the fact that , with elections fast approaching, the prevailing high cost of living has remained a defining factor in the political landscape. It is after the presidential and National Assembly elections which are scheduled for January 16, 2027, while the governorship and State Assembly elections will take place on February 6, 2027, both barely 60 days away are held that we will truly know who the voters are hinging their hope on.
The voters dilema is that even as those at the bottom rung of the societal ladder remain under the yoke of the high cost of living, largely owing to the sweeping reforms introduced by Tinubu, those operating at the macroeconomic level are basking in the benefits of the same reforms, as evidenced by the robust economic fundamentals acknowledged by both local and international rating agencies.
SO, THERE IS A PARADOX.
As a result of Tinubu’s bold reforms, Nigeria’s macroeconomy is improving. This is evidenced by the fact that foreign exchange (FX) reserves have grown to $55 billion, GDP growth is hovering between 4.3% and 4.6%, and oil production has risen to 1.6 million barrels per day. Banks declared profits of N6.7 trillion in 2024, while JPMorgan has relisted Nigeria on its Emerging Markets Index, from which the country had previously been removed owing to the parlous state of the economy. Consequently, access to foreign exchange has improved significantly, and manufacturers now have more reliable access to imported raw materials.
Given that the constraints arising from the economic impairments listed above had driven manufacturing businesses out of the Nigerian market, and they are currently returning, it is hard to miss the point which is that the significant improvements in the macroeconomic environment are hardly surprising.
Put succinctly, growth at the macroeconomic level has yet to cascade down to the grassroots. Consequently, SMEs are still struggling, while poverty remains widespread, as reflected in the fact that one pot of jollof rice still costs the equivalent of 37% of the minimum wage, according to SBM lntelligence ,an economic reseach firm whose survey recently revealed that grim statistics.
However, with the transportation allowance recently approved by Tinubu expected to be paid by the end of this month, the cost of preparing a pot of jollof rice may, by Christmas, begin trending downwards in relation to the minimum wage, from the current 37% to approximately 17% or less.
This could help ease the prevailing economic hardship just in time for the festivities: Christmas for Christians and the New Year celebrations for both Muslims and Christians alike.
The reason for the anticipated easing of the current harsh economic conditions is that the administration has approved an additional N70,000 as a transport allowance, beginning at the end of this month, November. Once paid, the allowance should provide some relief to hard-pressed Nigerians and potentially improve their purchasing power ahead of the Christmas and New Year festivities.
That effectively means that a low-income wage earner will be taking home N70,000 + N70,000 = N140,000 by the end of November. That should guarantee a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year celebration.
The second reason is that the N25,000 conditional direct cash payment to indigent Nigerians has also been doubled, representing a 100% increase to N50,000. Beneficiaries are also expected to start receiving the increased payment at the end of this month.
This will happen just before the Christmas and New Year festivities and approximately one month before the presidential election.
Right now, this may not be a major talking point, but it could turn out to be a game changer. The aphorism, “A hungry man is an angry man,” is particularly relevant here.
This is because a wage earner who is guaranteed to receive 100% more than he earned last month, and a beneficiary of the conditional direct cash transfer programme who is also set to receive 100% more than last month, will have every reason to be grateful to Tinubu and not to be angry which might have influenced his voting decision negatively. Such an intervention would be indicative of his promise to Nigerians: to renew their hope.
So, without a doubt, putting smiles on the faces of long-suffering Nigerian voters is likely to sway some voters in favour of President Tinubu, who has promised them an end to the tough times in his campaign commencement speech.
This is in addition to the increased spending by politicians during this campaign season as they struggle to appease the electorate, win their affection, earn their goodwill and secure their votes.
This is not necessarily about vote buying, but rather funds being invested by political office seekers in mobilising voters. Such spending has helped to reflate the economy, whether through radio and television jingles, newspaper advertisements or other campaign-related activities.
It is a whole story on its own, which I intend to tell after collating the quantum of funds expended so far and tracing how the money is flowing out of the vaults into the pockets of transporters conveying party supporters, printers producing campaign posters, hotels hosting politicians as they move from city to city and village to village, and those involved in door-to-door campaigns and the distribution of campaign largesse.
It is in the light of the foregoing that I have decided to juxtapose Nigeria of today against the backdrop of the United States of America (USA) during the Great Depression of the early 1930s. I have also compared the leadership styles of the two presidents who shaped America’s response to that economic crisis: Herbert Hoover, who was president when the Great Depression began, and Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who led the country out of the severe economic hardship that bears some resemblance to what Nigerians are currently experiencing as a result of economic reforms.
After making this comparison, I have come to the conclusion, based on the actions of both leaders and the parallels I have drawn between their administrations in different eras, that Tinubu is acting more like Roosevelt, one of the most outstanding presidents in American history.
Here is why:
President Herbert Hoover (1929–1933) promoted subsidies for institutions rather than individuals because he believed in what was described as ‘rugged individualism’. This philosophy held that government should not give money directly to individuals.
However, when the Great Depression struck, he broke his own rule in favour of the powerful.
He introduced the Federal Farm Board in 1929, providing $500 million to purchase surplus crops and support farm prices.
Hoover also established the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) in 1932, which provided $2 billion in loans to banks, railroads and insurance companies.
He further introduced the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, which sought to protect American manufacturers from foreign competition. The protectionist approach echoes the tariff war being waged by the current US President, J. Trump.
Disappointingly, Hoover also vetoed direct relief for the unemployed, the very opposite of what became the hallmark of his successor, Roosevelt. This meant that Hoover provided support to banks but not direct assistance to hungry families.
Is that not similar to what happened when ailing banks were bailed out in Nigeria while small and medium-scale enterprises (SMEs) struggled to survive?
As a consequence of these policies, poor Americans of that era named their shantytowns “Hoovervilles” and referred to their newspapers as “Hoover blankets”.
I submit that, since May 29, 2023, Nigeria has been moving away from the Hoover-style of economic management towards the Roosevelt template.
Again, below is the justification for this assertion:
In stark contrast to Hoover, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1933–1945) promoted subsidies for people and production.
Roosevelt reversed the direction of government support through his New Deal programmes, which provided people with opportunities to earn a living while contributing to national development. Through initiatives such as the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and the Works Progress Administration (WPA), his administration employed approximately 8.5 million unemployed Americans to build roads, dams, schools and parks. This was productive employment, not mere handouts.
It is not by sheer coincidence that a similar concept is being replicated by Tinubu’s administration, which has embarked on massive infrastructure development programmes, including the construction of the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway and the Badagry-Sokoto Highway, providing employment opportunities for thousands of Nigerians at both professional and artisanal levels.
The port rehabilitation initiative, reportedly backed by a £740 billion loan from Citibank, guaranteed by the UK government, is another Roosevelt-style initiative aimed at stimulating economic recovery.
Similarly, under Roosevelt’s Agricultural Adjustment Administration (AAA), farmers were paid to manage agricultural supply, with the initiative also incorporating soil conservation measures. In the same vein, under Tinubu’s administration, farmers are being empowered through increased funding and agricultural extension services.
Let us also not forget that, under the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) arrangement, Roosevelt’s administration built power plants to industrialise the impoverished American South. In a similar fashion, Tinubu’s administration has opened up Nigeria’s electricity sector through the Electricity Act 2023, allowing subnational governments and private-sector investors to participate in electricity generation and distribution through initiatives such as mini-grids. This is expected to move Nigeria towards energy independence in the foreseeable future.
Finally, it was Roosevelt who introduced the Social Security Act of 1935, which established America’s first national social safety net. Tinubu’s administration is also pursuing a similar path through its poverty alleviation programmes, which, according to the Minister, Bernard Doro, have reached more than 15 million indigent families.
It can therefore be argued that Roosevelt’s approach to subsidies created productive assets and expanded opportunities for ordinary citizens, while Hoover’s interventions largely protected assets already owned by the wealthy.
In Nigeria’s case, the removal of petrol subsidies has also meant ending a system that primarily benefited powerful interests, including petrol importers who allegedly engaged in round-tripping, over-invoicing and other fraudulent practices to milk our commonwealth.
However, because the benefits of these policies have a long gestation period before they become fully visible, the administration is still struggling to convince Nigerians that it means well and that its actions today are intended to guarantee a better life tomorrow.
The Lesson for Nigeria.
Nigeria before Tinubu’s reforms was much like Hoover’s America.
This is because, before now, we were subsidising fuel importers rather than local refineries, as Tinubu has sought to do by ending the petrol subsidy regime and supporting the Dangote Refinery. This support has come not only through the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)’s equity investment but also through the multiple measures taken to ensure that the refinery can procure Nigerian crude oil locally.
It is hard to believe that we were subsidising banks through CBN intervention funds rather than supporting small manufacturers, particularly small and medium-scale enterprises (SMEs), which are the engine of any economy and among the largest employers of labour.
That is not all. We were also subsidising politicians through constituency projects rather than adequately supporting farmers with irrigation facilities and cold-room storage chains for preserving perishable produce that is perennially wasted in Nigeria’s food-producing zones because of inadequate storage infrastructure.
Scandalously, there was a time in Nigeria when some of us regarded cash transfers to the poor as a “waste”, yet we described a $2 billion loan to failing banks as “stabilisation”. That was an attitude taken straight out of Hoover’s playbook.
As I have emphasised throughout this five-part series of articles on how poverty can be alleviated and prosperity cascaded from the macroeconomic to the microeconomic level, Nigeria does not need Hoover-style subsidies-consumption oriented. We need Roosevelt-style subsidies: productive money that builds a dam, a factory, a farm and empowers a worker, rather than money that disappears into bank vaults, as often happens when the wealthy benefit from such interventions, or evaporates through the consumption of petrol by fuel-guzzling SUVs, thereby amounting to subsidising the rich who can afford such big cars.
Now, some critics may argue that the suffering experienced by Nigerians during the past three and a half years of economic reforms is not comparable to the Great Depression of the 1930s in the United States and, as such, Tinubu cannot be compared to Roosevelt.
My counterargument would be that the models adopted by Roosevelt do not have to be exactly the same as those being implemented by Tinubu. They only need to be sufficiently similar for one to draw parallels between the two leaders. We must also take into consideration the dynamics of change and the passage of time, given that Roosevelt led the United States almost 100 years ago. Indeed, even those same policies might not produce identical results in America today.
Therefore, arguing that Tinubu has not done exactly what Roosevelt did and that, consequently, no parallel can be drawn between the two leaders is not cogent. This is because all we need to establish is that both Tinubu and Roosevelt share common development principles, particularly the principle of subsidising production rather than consumption. That is indisputable.
This is underscored by the fact that Tinubu ended a petrol subsidy regime that had been in existence for nearly 50 years and redirected resources towards initiatives such as the Nigerian Education Loan Fund (NELFUND), which represents an investment in human capital development rather than consumption. Tinubu has also toed Roosevelts footsteps through his massive investments in infrastructure, especially roads, bridges, ports and railines with plan to engage in agricultural pursuits after restoring security as he has laid out in his five (5) years security plan recently inveiled.
Similarly, the argument that Roosevelt provided education grants while Tinubu is offering education loans also misses the point. Both are investments in human resources, which, by all standards, are classified as inputs into human capital development.
As I stated earlier, it is the underlying principle that matters, not the granular details.
One cannot, in good conscience, argue against the fact that there has clearly been a paradigm shift from subsidising consumption to subsidising production under Tinubu’s watch. That is what matters in this context.
As I argued in the previous articles in this series, of which this is the fifth instalment, it takes between 24 and 36 months to establish a factory capable of creating employment, wealth and prosperity for Nigerians.
A practical illustration of the length of time required to establish a factory is the fact that Aliko Dangote spent seven years building his petroleum refinery.
The reality is that the factories being established by those currently making money at the macroeconomic level will eventually create employment and prosperity for people at the bottom of the economic pyramid, and the professionals like engineers, doctors, lawyers which represent the middle and microeconomic levels. The truth is that Tinubu has been at the helm of Nigeria’s affairs for less than four years, while, as I have pointed out, establishing a factory can take between 24 and 36 months.
If the superstructure, such as the beams on which the slab rests in a typical road bridge, is not first constructed to provide a solid foundation, how can the slab on which vehicles will travel be laid? I hope readers will permit me to use this analogy of bridge construction to explain my argument.
So, in my view, President Tinubu has done the right thing by fixing the economy at the macroeconomic level first.
Based on his Renewed Hope Agenda 2.0, unveiled at the Yar’Adua Centre in Abuja and as he had earlier promised during the flag-off of his re-election campaign at the Ranchers Bees Stadium in Kaduna in October, his priority goal will be to ensure that the wealth and prosperity currently evident at the macroeconomic level cascade down to the microeconomic level. This, in turn, should help stem the current hue and cry among poor Nigerians at the lower end of the economic spectrum.
According to his newly unveiled manifesto, President Tinubu is now poised to use his second term to cascade prosperity from the macroeconomic to the microeconomic level.
This is consistent with his campaign promise to focus on agriculture, the construction of cold-room storage chains, the provision of agricultural extension services, improved seedlings and the creation of better access routes for moving produce from farms to cities and, ultimately, to consumers’ kitchens. These are initiatives that Anambra State Governor, Professor Charles Soludo, is already pursuing in his state.
The 105-page pact with Nigerians, which is essentially what a manifesto represents, also contains similarly transformative proposals for other sectors of the economy. What this suggests is that Tinubu is not planning to wait for the traditional trickle-down process to take effect before providing relief to the critical mass of Nigerians currently under tremendous socioeconomic pressure.
Rather, he can intervene directly at the bottom of the economic spectrum to stimulate economic activity and accelerate growth beyond its normal pace. This would enable those at the grassroots to catch up with the prosperity cascading from the macroeconomic level, allowing both processes to meet halfway and positively impact society much faster.
In that regard, in my previous interventions, I have encouraged and urged President Tinubu to consider deploying 50% of the $1 billion earmarked for compressed natural gas (CNG) initiatives towards funding the production of electric-vehicle (EV) Okadas and Keke tricycles.
Such an initiative would not only improve mobility, as tricycles and motorcycles (three- and two-wheelers, respectively) serve as our equivalent of the mass-transit rail systems found in advanced industrialised economies, but would also create employment opportunities for the huge number of commercial riders through ride-to-own models.
This would leave the beneficiaries with assets rather than simply burning petrol in SUVs, as happens under a system of petrol consumption subsidies.
I could go on and on establishing the connections between the principles underlying Roosevelt’s and Tinubu’s production-oriented subsidy policies. Suffice it to say, however, that although it is not yet uhuru, as we say in Africa, Tinubu appears to be on track towards pulling the Nigerian economy, and by extension Nigerians, out of the doldrums.
Fittingly, the first taste of the pudding, as conventional wisdom suggests, will come during the fast-approaching Christmas and New Year festivities, when public servants are expected to receive their first improved wages, together with transport allowances, while beneficiaries of conditional cash transfers will receive payments that have been increased by 100%.
To make the relief inclusive, the All Progressives Congress (APC)-dominated state governments, which control 32 of the 36 states, should move quickly to replicate at the subnational level the enhanced wage and transport allowance arrangements being implemented by the Federal Government.
Since private-sector employers often take their cue from the Federal Government, they too should be encouraged to improve their workers’ pay packages, using the same nomenclature: transport allowance.
If that happens, we can all join in singing Young John’s chart-busting hit, Elumelu: “I see the morning coming”, as we wrap up 2026 and enter 2027 with renewed hope and confidence.
Magnus Onyibe, an entrepreneur, public policy analyst, author, democracy advocate, development strategist, an alumnus of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Tufts University, Massachusetts, USA, a Commonwealth Institute scholar, and a former commissioner in the Delta State government, sent this piece from Lagos.

